Former employee data requests: how to respond

Three months after leaving, a former sales rep sends the company a six-page letter. He wants to know who has accessed his email since he left, why his account still exists, whether his messages were forwarded to his replacement, a copy of all his emails, and the removal of his photo from Teams and the website. He cites foreign laws and sets a ten-day deadline. It was almost certainly written with AI.

Requests like this now reach HR teams and DPOs every day. The short answer: the request is valid even if AI wrote it, the deadline to respond is one month, and each question has a different legal answer. Whatever the company has done with the former employee’s email since the day they left is exactly what is put to the test.

Has a former employee asked for their data? We review the logs, prepare the response and document it. Tell us about your case →

Why former employees are now asking for their data

An employee who leaves, especially after a dispute, has reasons to ask for their data: preparing a claim, checking whether their email was read, or simply closing the relationship. AI tools produce in minutes a letter that asks for everything at once, mixing rights and citing legal references that often do not exist.

We have already explained how to handle these requests in our guide on AI-generated subject access requests, based on the guidance published by the UK regulator (ICO). Here we focus on what a former employee asks and how to answer each point under Spanish and EU law.

How to recognise the typical AI-written letter

Almost all the AI-written letters we receive from former employees share the same features:

  • An invented deadline, usually ten or fifteen days. The GDPR gives one month from receipt (Article 12(3)), extendable by two further months if the request is complex and the requester is told within the first month.
  • Several rights mixed in one letter: access, erasure, rectification, objection, restriction and portability, sometimes all at once and without distinguishing what is being asked in each case.
  • Concepts that are not data protection rights, such as the Spanish constitutional “amparo” appeal, the “right to effective judicial protection” or “secrecy of communications” invoked as if it were a right exercised against the company.
  • Laws and decisions that do not exist or do not apply in Spain, such as Californian or UK rules, or rulings nobody can find.
  • A final threat: if there is no reply within the deadline set in the letter, they will go to the Spanish Data Protection Agency (AEPD) or “the competent supervisory authority”.

How to respond to it

However, none of this invalidates the request. As the UK regulator (ICO) pointed out in the guidance we analyse in our article on AI-generated subject access requests, a request does not stop being valid because it was written with AI or contains errors or “hallucinations”. What changes is how you respond:

  • The legal deadline applies, not the one in the letter. There is no need to reply in ten days, but there is no point in using the whole month unnecessarily either.
  • Each right is answered separately. Anything that is not a data protection right is explained in one sentence and redirected to its proper route, without arguing about it.
  • There is no need to rebut invented laws one by one. It is enough to state which rules apply and answer what is relevant.
  • The threat to go to the AEPD changes nothing. That right always exists and the response must mention it. The best defence against a complaint is a response that is timely, complete and documented.
  • Talking to the former employee, where the relationship allows, helps to pin down what they want and usually lowers the tone.

What a former employee usually asks for and how to respond

What they askRight exercisedHow to respond
Who accessed their emailAccess (Art. 15 GDPR)Say whether there were accesses, when and why; the identity of who accessed, in principle not
Why their account has not been deletedAccess and erasure (Arts. 15 and 17)Explain what is kept, why and until when, or delete it
Whether their messages were forwardedAccess (Art. 15)Tell the truth: it is part of the processing
A copy of all their emailsAccess (Art. 15)A copy of their personal data, protecting third parties and trade secrets
Removal of their photo from Teams or the websiteErasure or objection (Arts. 17 and 21)Remove it, unless there is a specific reason to keep it
Deletion of everythingErasure (Art. 17)Delete what is no longer needed and restrict what must be kept

“Who has accessed my email?”

This is the question that worries companies most. The Court of Justice of the EU answered it in case C-579/21 (Pankki S, 22 June 2023): the data subject has the right to the information in the logs of consultations of their data, such as the dates and purposes of those consultations. However, they are not in principle entitled to know the identity of the employees who consulted the data acting on the company’s instructions. That identity would only have to be disclosed if it were essential for them to exercise their rights, weighing the interests of those employees.

In practice, the company must be able to say whether anyone accessed the mailbox after the departure, when and why. That requires access logs. A company without them cannot prove that nobody read the email, and that has already led to fines. In decision 101/2026, the Belgian authority fined a large technology company €176,946.61 for keeping a consultant’s mailbox active for more than a year after she left, partly because it could not show that nobody had accessed it. The decision is under appeal.

“Why has my account not been deleted?”

Neither the GDPR nor Spanish law sets a maximum period for keeping a former employee’s address. What the GDPR does require is that data is not kept longer than necessary (Article 5(1)(e)) and that the company can justify the period chosen (Article 5(2)).

The European authorities that have ruled on this agree on one approach: block access on the day of departure, keep only an automatic reply for a short period, and delete afterwards. The Belgian authority considers one month reasonable, extendable to three depending on the role, and has repeated this in several decisions since 2020. We have not found a decision of the Spanish Data Protection Agency (AEPD) setting a specific period.

If the account is still active, the response must explain what is kept, for what purpose and until when. If there is no specific reason, the right thing is to delete it.

“Did you forward my messages?”

Tell the truth. The recipients of the data and the way it has been processed are part of the information covered by the right of access. Automatically forwarding email to a replacement or a manager is the most sanctioned practice in Europe: the Belgian authority fined it €15,000 in decision 64/2020, and the Norwegian regulator has fined it several times. The alternative every authority accepts is an automatic reply announcing the departure and giving another contact, with nobody reading the messages.

If there was forwarding, the reply to the former employee is not the moment to hide it. It is the moment to stop it and review the protocol, because the request may be followed by a complaint to the AEPD.

“I want a copy of all my emails”

The right of access gives the right to a copy of the data subject’s personal data, not necessarily of every original document. But authorities disagree on the scope when it comes to a mailbox:

  • The Italian Garante (decision 165/2026) considers that emails in an individual account are the account holder’s data even when work-related, and ordered full access. It fined an insurer €50,000 for providing only the “strictly personal” messages.
  • The Belgian authority (decision 134/2025) accepts providing a copy of the personal data rather than complete documents, but considers it unjustified to refuse mixed and professional emails wholesale without reasons. In decision 101/2026 it added that limiting the search by date is not acceptable, although filtering out trade secrets is.

In Spain we have not found a specific AEPD position. The prudent approach is to provide the former employee’s data contained in the mailbox, protect third parties’ data (Article 15(4) GDPR) and document any exclusion for trade secrets. And a practical rule: the longer the mailbox is kept, the bigger the job of answering these requests. Once one has been received, the mailbox must not be deleted until it has been resolved.

“Remove my photo from Teams and the website”

A person’s photograph is personal data. When the employee leaves, their profile photo in Teams, the intranet or the company directory no longer has a purpose, and it normally disappears when the account is disabled. Their name and photo on the website, shared signatures or sales materials should be removed as soon as they leave.

If the photo was published with their consent, for example on social media or the website, the former employee can withdraw it at any time. If the company used it on the basis of legitimate interest, they can object (Article 21 GDPR). Unless there is a specific reason, such as a corporate video already edited and distributed, which will need to be assessed, the reasonable response is to remove it.

Messages the former employee wrote in shared chats or channels are a different matter: they are part of work conversations with other people and may be kept for the period the company has set, although they contain the former employee’s data and fall within the right of access.

“Delete all my data”

The right to erasure has exceptions. The company must keep the data the law requires (contracts, payslips, social security records, tax documentation) and may keep what is needed to bring or defend legal claims (Article 17(3) GDPR). Where erasure applies but the law requires the data to be kept, the Spanish Data Protection Act (LOPDGDD) requires it to be restricted: set aside, unused, available only to courts and authorities during the limitation periods (Article 32).

The response should separate what is deleted, what is restricted and for how long.

What the company should have done before the departure

A request like this is easy to answer if things were done properly on the day of departure. The approach followed by European authorities comes down to these steps:

  1. An email use policy communicated to staff, with the involvement of employee representatives (Article 87 LOPDGDD).
  2. Handover of work before departure, and an opportunity for the employee to remove personal messages.
  3. Access blocked on the last day, removing forwarding rules and delegations.
  4. A neutral automatic reply for a short period, without mentioning the reason for leaving and stating that the person no longer works at the company. Nobody reads incoming messages.
  5. Never hand the mailbox to the successor. If specific information is needed, it is extracted through a targeted, authorised and logged search.
  6. Scheduled deletion of the address, mailbox, profile photo and website references, with evidence that it has been done.

We develop this protocol, with nine cases sanctioned in Europe, in our article on what to do with a former employee’s email account.

How to respond to the request, step by step

  1. Log the date of receipt. The one-month period starts.
  2. Check identity and the reply address. If they ask for the reply at an address different from the one on file, confirm before sending anything.
  3. Freeze any deletion of the mailbox or affected data while the request is handled.
  4. Separate each request by the right exercised: access, erasure, objection or simple complaints.
  5. Review the access logs for the mailbox and the account configuration since the departure.
  6. Prepare the copy of the data, protecting third parties and documenting exclusions.
  7. Respond within the month, clearly and point by point, without rebutting invented legal references.
  8. Fix whatever went wrong: stop forwarding, remove the photo, schedule deletion.

Common mistakes

  • Ignoring the request because it was written with AI or cites laws that do not exist.
  • Deleting the mailbox on receiving it. It can be seen as frustrating the right of access and aggravates any later complaint.
  • Stating that nobody accessed it without logs to prove it.
  • Providing only personal emails and refusing the rest without justification.
  • Keeping the former employee’s photo or name on the website or directory months later.
  • Mentioning the reason for leaving in the automatic reply or in messages to clients.

How we can help

As external data protection officers, we handle former employees’ data requests every day, many of them already written with AI: we review the logs, prepare the response and document every step. We also draft the email use policy and the exit protocol so the next request is straightforward. If you have one on your desk, tell us about your case.

Frequently asked questions

Can a former employee find out who accessed their email?

They can find out whether there were consultations, when and for what purpose. According to the Court of Justice of the EU, they are not in principle entitled to know the identity of the employees who accessed it on the company’s behalf, unless that is essential to exercise their rights.

How long can a company keep a former employee’s email account?

There is no legal period in Spain. European authorities consider one month with an automatic reply reasonable, extendable to three depending on the role, with deletion afterwards. The company must be able to justify the period it applies.

Are they entitled to a copy of all their emails?

They are entitled to a copy of their personal data, which includes data contained in their mailbox. Third parties’ data must be protected, and trade secrets can be excluded with justification. European authorities do not agree on the exact scope.

Should their photo be removed from Teams and the website?

Yes, unless there is a specific reason to keep it. The photo no longer has a purpose once they leave and, if it was published with their consent, they can withdraw it at any time.

Can the company refuse to delete their data?

It can keep data required by law or needed to defend against claims. In that case it must restrict that data and explain what it keeps and until when.

This article provides general information and is not a substitute for legal advice on a specific case.